Metrorail's Year of Chaos

We host one of the Seven Wonders of the World and this year Cape Town was also the World Design Capital, unfortunately two days after the annual Cape Town Carnival, thousands were stranded and frustrated when trains were delayed by more than an hour.

The mess took place because a train derailed, a week after Transport minister, Dipuo Peters, took a train and engaged with commuters.

Back in March I wrote that Monday 17 March is probably a day Metrorail staff and commuters would not like to see be repeated – unfortunately it was.

On numerous occasions I’ve said that with our old infrastructure and stock, we will probably see more delays and who really knows when the new trains will be operational.

Metrorail’s year in a nutshell can only be described as chaos. The only good story would possible be GoMetro (which is not operated by Metrorail) and then there’s the Twitter handle @CapeTownTrains.

Metrorail’s overall communication though was not up to standard, definitely something a commuter should not count on (I’m trying not to use the words incompetent). The fact that their website had a slow death is not helping them either. Besides the lack of communication, there’s also a lack of senior staff when all hell breaks loose…

I was privileged enough to visit Metrorail’s Operational Centre, I also build extremely good relationships with Metrorail staff and was even described by Transport Minister, Dipuo Peters’ as Metrorail’s number one critic (and I haven’t failed at doing that).

Despite their Year of Chaos, senior Metrorail staff still fails to understand the frustration of commuters when trains are delayed. This statement I make because not once when trains were delayed for more than 30minutes, did any senior manager of Metrorail/Prasa take a train with commuters.

EMPTY PROMISES

On Tuesday 25^th March, former Regional Manager Mthura Swartz announced safety critical interventions. There were no time frames and deadlines and the four months added later, was clearly missed. Other measures announced:

• Metrorail in a way stabilized the railway network, but was hit by cable theft and their response: we apologise for the inconvenience.
• The commuter I am, expected atleast better customer service and communication, I’m still waiting on that.
• A second train for Worcester was also announced, and we still waiting on that empty promise.
• Their sms system was revived, and I can actually understand why it had a slow death – it’s more delayed than trains.
• The Twitter handle has moved from updating every 20 to 30 minutes to more frequently and even engage with commuters (atleast something Metrorail can be proud of).
• Despite recommending that the MyLine be used more proactive, it is now being advertised and handed out. I still feel it is a waste of money.

Metrorail’s problem is not having an integrated policy/strategy for their departments and a Customer Services and Communication sections in it. This I told them in April.

I also shared with them not to complicate things and give certain technical information with illustrations and images. There’s slow progress with this though.

I also advised Metrorail to be more honest with commuters and there’s even progress with this.

FREE WI-FI

In June free Wi-Fi at Cape Town station was promised and I welcomed this by saying Metrorail cannot promise a reliable service in 2014, they could promise better communication and customer service and give the Wi-Fi as some sort of compensation.

As we know better communication, customer service and Wi-Fi are all delayed with the trains.

Cables were installed and there’s actually Wi-Fi on Cape Town station, but due to some issues and Metrorail’s forever red tape, this is not announced.

Wi-Fi is not and can never be a substitute for the poor service, Metrorail should be applauded for the initiative though – that’s once they decide to implement it

Despite Metrorail’s missed opportunity, Metrorail’s delay, Lack of Communication, empty WiFi promise, they do have a good story to tell, their RailTourism train.

While I might have lost hope in some senior staff, it is Metrorail’s good story and my continuous interaction with senior Metrorail staff that I still have hope. 

Metrorail's delay

Metrorail missed their own deadline for reporting back, following an announcement by the former regional manager of Metrorail Western Cape, Mthuthuzeli Swartz, on Tuesday 25^th March 2014 that safety critical interventions will be implemented to stabilize the rail service.

Back in March I wrote in my CapeTown Trains is Metrorail’s eToll that the interventions have no time-frames and deadlines for implementation.  

In personal interactions and in the media Metrorail then said these interventions will be implemented over the next four months. I still said back then, there are some interventions that should be implemented immediately, starting with better communication.

Now before I get to some of the interventions, Swartz left the failing (yes failing) rail service and Richard Walker, no stranger to the Western Cape, came in the hot seat. Walker came just as Prasa announced ticket prices will be increasing and this frustrated commuters even more.

Back in March, Metrorail got a R233million life-jacket to implement critical safety interventions and stabilize the service. This included:

• Track circuits and use of suitable technology
• Overhaul of track transformers
• Building of closer-by station for commuters in the Wallacedene area in Kraaifontein was added to planning
• Upgrading of a few stations
• A second train to Worcester was in the negotiation process in March, as well as using the Shosholoza Meyl to alleviate capacity constraints.
• Metrorail’s sms system would be resuscitated

The interventions came a few days after Transport Minister Dipuo Peters took a train from Kraaifontein to Cape Town station. It is interesting to note than that issues shared with the minister by regular commuters (as per her press release then) but did not form part of Metrorail’s interventions included:

• Dirty trains
• Broken windows
• Lack of ticket verification
• Security in peak times

Metrorail have been ignoring a few questions as well:

• Why did they wait until a second train derailed and damaged tracks leading to the closure of platforms at Cape Town, before interventions were implemented?
• Why can no one take responsibility?
• Why did Prasa wait (on the minister to listen to commuters) before more than R233 million was made available for urgent interventions?
• Did a certain manager not do their job to report tracks need urgent upgrades?
• Why can’t Metrorail/Prasa admit that they have failed to deliver an effective reliable rail service to communicate?

From a commuter perspective what was done?

• Trains are still delayed due to faulty track circuits
• Only building one can see is that of the new Operation Centre in Bellville (yes a new Ops Centre is being build there – that deserves its own blog).
• A few stations were upgraded
• The Worcester train is more faulty leaving commuters to travel more by bus, than a second train.
• The sms-system is being used again, but sms’ seems to be more delayed at times than trains.
• Trains are still dirty, windows broken and sometimes you even have to pack a swimsuit for a commute.
• There is still no security on trains, something I personally have been asking for more than a year now. I was told Metrorail is engaging with SAPS on the matter, it’s been more than twelve months – two ticket price hikes later and still no response from Metrorail.

Metrorail started rolling out wifi, this would have gone live in end of June/July - we basically in Spring, and not WiFi. In June I wrote Is free Wi-Fi good or bad for Metrorail

Metrorail has not only failed to deliver an effective and reliable service but also to give a report back on the safety critical interventions that would have taken four months. Unless Metrorail is using a different calendar, the four months ended, 25 days after the ticket prices increased, in July.

Is free Wi-Fi good or bad for Metrorail

Metrorail announced that it would be rolling out free Wi-Fi on Cape Town station later this month and soon after that on the Southern line, before extending this to other lines. This benefit comes despite the crippling service where daily you hear of delays. I was asked do I agree with the Wi-Fi benefit.

This is my answer:

We should admit that yes Metrorail Western Cape is in the ICU and the service will not get better overnight (okay within three to six or even 12months). The lack of service is something I mentioned in a previous blog: Visiting critical but not stable Metrorail

While one can do the blame-game, this will not better the service and that is what should receive attention.

Metrorail Western Cape cannot promise a reliable service within 2014, but they can promise better communication with and to commuters with dedicated staff. They can also promise to take atleast once a week a train in peak-time to understand the frustration of commuters. 

Al read: Another day Another delay 

Now about Wi-Fi:

Data cost in the country is expensive, no matter which network provider you use. Anyone with a smartphone, using data will welcome free Wi-Fi.

Considering the delays and most people make use of social networks like bbm, whatsapp, Facebook and Twitter – if you late because your train is delay or has been cancelled and you need to take another one, you will now atleast not have to make use of your own data but the free Wi-Fi that Metrorail is providing, to inform your loved ones that you will be late and give an estimated time of when they can expect you.

I would think that students would be happy about this announcement as they can now download music with the free Wi-Fi and even movies.

Mthura Swartz, outgoing regional manager Metrorail Western Cape, explains
the Metrorail Wi-Fi

So do I agree with it?

If it’s Metrorail’s way of keeping commuters quiet? Then without a second thought, NO!
If it’s their way to try and compensate commuters? I agree and disagree. I agree because they want to compensate commuters but disagree for not keeping ticket prices the same in the current financial year due to the service being critical.

If it’s Metrorail’s way of admitting the digital world is expanding and want to give commuters added value? Then I agree.

Wi-Fi is not and can never be a substitute for the poor service, but Metrorail should be commended for this benefit that commuters will be enjoying. My only hope now is that Metrorail will better their communication and customer service.